SCUBAPRO Aladin One Matrix vs Mares Puck 4:which one should you choose?
If you are looking for your first dive computer, these two models start from a similar idea: a simple display, Bluetooth, a user-replaceable battery and controls designed not to make things unnecessarily complicated. But underneath, they are quite different.
I use the SCUBAPRO Aladin One Matrix as my own dive computer, so this comparison includes around 20 real dives with it. I have not personally used the Mares Puck 4: for that model, I compare its official specifications with what I already know I value underwater after using the Aladin.
The Aladin One Matrix feels easier to understand if you want a straightforward recreational dive computer. On paper, the Puck 4 offers more room to grow: Bühlmann ZH-L16C with customisable gradient factors, support for up to three gases and firmware updates through the app.
Aladin One Matrix vs Puck 4: main differences
| Feature | SCUBAPRO Aladin One Matrix | Mares Puck 4 |
|---|---|---|
| Controls | 2 buttons | 1 button |
| Algorithm | ZH-L16 ADT MB | Bühlmann ZH-L16C with customisable gradient factors |
| Gas management | Single gas | Up to 3 gases |
| Nitrox | 21–50% O₂ | Yes, with multi-gas capability |
| Bluetooth | Yes | Yes |
| App | SCUBAPRO LogTRAK | Mares / SSI app |
| Battery | User-replaceable CR2450 | User-replaceable CR2450 |
| Claimed battery life | Approx. 2 years or 300 dives | Approx. 100 dives |
| Internal logbook | Profiles for around 25 hours of diving | 100 dives |
| Firmware updates from app | Not highlighted by SCUBAPRO as a feature of this model | Yes |
| Strap | Traditional strap | Removable strap with bungee option |
| My first-hand experience | Around 20 dives | Not personally tested |
What the Aladin One Matrix gives me
I bought it as my first personal dive computer, and after around 20 dives what I value most is that I do not have to think too much about the computer itself while I am underwater.
- The display is clear and quick for me to read.
- The two-button layout feels easy to understand.
- The backlight has been useful on night dives.
- Bluetooth and LogTRAK let me review dives afterwards.
- The CR2450 battery is user-replaceable.
What I like least is the rather long strap and the care needed when fitting the screen protector properly.
Read my Aladin reviewWhat the Mares Puck 4 offers
The Puck 4 is also designed to be accessible, but its specifications give it more room to grow if you later want more control over decompression settings or multi-gas diving.
- Bühlmann ZH-L16C algorithm.
- Customisable gradient factors.
- Up to three gases.
- Integrated Bluetooth.
- 100-dive logbook.
- User-replaceable CR2450 battery.
- Firmware updates through the app.
- Removable strap with bungee option.
All of that looks good on paper. What I cannot judge without using it is how I would personally find the one-button navigation or how its display would compare directly underwater.
Two buttons vs one button: which control system makes more sense?
This looks like a small difference on paper, but it matters quite a lot when you are starting out.
The Aladin One Matrix uses two buttons. Once I got used to it, moving through the options and checking information felt natural. For a first dive computer, I like having the actions separated a little more clearly.
The Puck 4 keeps the classic Mares philosophy of using one button. That reduces the number of physical controls and can make operation very direct once you learn the short-press and long-press logic. But I would not assume that one button automatically means easier for everyone.
The biggest technical difference is the algorithm and room to progress
The Aladin One Matrix uses the ZH-L16 ADT MB algorithm and is designed around a single gas. For the recreational diving I currently do, that has not limited me.
The Puck 4 uses Bühlmann ZH-L16C and allows customisable gradient factors. It also supports up to three gases. That matters if you want a computer with more room to grow into additional training and more advanced configurations without replacing it too soon.
That does not mean an Open Water or Advanced diver needs those functions from day one. On many normal recreational dives you may never touch them. The difference is the amount of headroom the computer gives you for the future.
Bluetooth: both cover the basics well on paper
The Aladin One Matrix can transfer dives over Bluetooth, and I use LogTRAK to review profiles and dive data afterwards.
The Puck 4 also includes Bluetooth, allowing dives to be downloaded directly to a compatible device through the Mares or SSI app. The Puck 4 can also receive firmware updates through the app.
Bluetooth is not essential for the dive itself, but it is a feature I have come to value since owning my own computer. It removes the need for extra cables and makes it easier to keep a record of my dives.
Both use a user-replaceable CR2450 battery
This is something I like about both models. SCUBAPRO and Mares both use a CR2450 battery that the user can replace.
SCUBAPRO states an estimated battery life of around two years or 300 dives for the Aladin One Matrix, while Mares quotes around 100 dives for the Puck 4.
I would not use those figures to claim that one lasts exactly three times longer than the other. They are estimates from different manufacturers, and real battery life depends on factors such as dive duration, temperature, backlight use and connection frequency.
Which one makes more sense for each type of diver?
I would look at the Aladin One Matrix if you mainly want simplicity, clear readability, two buttons and a recreational dive computer that does not make you pay for functions you may never use. It is also the model I can speak about from first-hand experience.
I would look closely at the Puck 4 if, even as a first dive computer, you want more technical headroom: gradient factors, multi-gas capability, firmware updates and more configuration options for the future.
For a recreational diver who simply wants to monitor depth, time, no-decompression limits, safety stops and keep a dive log, both go well beyond the basics. The decision comes down more to how much you value immediate simplicity versus room to progress.
I would consider it if…
- It is your first dive computer and you want simplicity.
- You prefer two buttons.
- Your diving is mainly recreational.
- You value a display I have already found easy to read underwater.
- You do not need multi-gas capability or custom gradient factors.
I would consider it if…
- You want more technical room to progress.
- You are interested in Bühlmann ZH-L16C.
- You want customisable gradient factors.
- You are interested in multi-gas capability.
- You value firmware updates through the app.
- You like the option of replacing the strap with a bungee.
What about price?
Prices for this type of dive computer can vary a lot depending on colour, retailer and promotions. That is why I would not base the comparison on one fixed number that may be outdated a few months from now.
I would compare the real price of both on the day you are buying. If they are very close, the Puck 4’s extra functions carry more weight. If you find the Aladin One Matrix clearly cheaper and your goal is straightforward recreational diving, it still makes a lot of sense.
FAQ: Aladin One Matrix vs Mares Puck 4
Which one is easier for a beginner?
The Aladin One Matrix has felt simple to me as a first dive computer and uses two buttons. The Puck 4 uses one button. I have not personally tested the Puck 4, so I would not claim that one is universally easier than the other.
Do both have Bluetooth?
Yes. The Aladin One Matrix can sync dive data through LogTRAK, while the Puck 4 includes Bluetooth for transferring dives to the Mares or SSI app.
Do both use a replaceable battery?
Yes. Both use a user-replaceable CR2450 battery, provided the manufacturer’s replacement procedure is followed correctly to preserve the seal.
Which one offers more room to progress?
Based on specifications, the Puck 4 offers more: Bühlmann ZH-L16C with customisable gradient factors, multi-gas support for up to three gases and firmware updates through the app.
Have I personally tested both computers?
No. I use the SCUBAPRO Aladin One Matrix and this comparison includes around 20 dives of first-hand experience. My analysis of the Mares Puck 4 is based on specifications published by Mares.
Which one would I buy as a first dive computer?
It would depend on price and what you expect to do later. For straightforward recreational diving, the Aladin One Matrix still fits very well with what I wanted. If you want more technical headroom from the beginning, the Puck 4 has broader specifications.
More guides for building your first scuba kit
Two good first dive computers,but not designed for exactly the same priorities.
The Aladin One Matrix has worked well for me because I wanted simplicity and clear readability. On paper, the Puck 4 goes further in configuration options and room to progress.
Before buying, I would compare the real price of both and decide how much those extra functions matter to you. For me, that difference matters more than choosing purely by brand.
